Shelter Island Moving Companies 2024

Compare movers in Shelter Island and save 50% off moving cost
Save Money with Competitive Quotes
We Have Over 10,000 Movers in USA
Shelter Island
Why Use Authority Movers?
Save time and money

You'll get custom quotes for your exact needs.

No hidden fees

Full breakdown, all inclusive, fixed fee conveyancing quotes.

Compare Online

Quick and easy conveyancing costs comparison.

Real Reviews

Genuine rated and reviewed moving companies.

Thomas L. Jernick, Inc. Unclaimed
16 Saint Mary s Road Shelter Island, NY 11964 USA

Recent review:

andrea villani
Jan 29, 2020

Jernick moving & Storage is the most amazing company. I have used them three times now moving homes from Long Island to Florida. The drivers and movers are the most professional , reliable and down right nice people. Our things arrived unbroken and stacked perfectly. The movers received outstanding compliments from the manager of the storage facility in Florida. She said this is the best company she has had the pleasure of meeting. Jernick movers are fair in pricing and extremely reliable. I recommend Jernick Moving & Storage to everyone who is moving anything to anywhere! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Andrea from Long Island

4.9 / 5
based on 8 reviews
Jernick Moving & Storage Inc Unclaimed
16 St Mary's Rd Shelter Island, NY 11964 USA

Recent review:

andrea villani
Jan 29, 2020

Jernick moving & Storage is the most amazing company. I have used them three times now moving homes from Long Island to Florida. The drivers and movers are the most professional , reliable and down right nice people. Our things arrived unbroken and stacked perfectly. The movers received outstanding compliments from the manager of the storage facility in Florida. She said this is the best company she has had the pleasure of meeting. Jernick movers are fair in pricing and extremely reliable. I recommend Jernick Moving & Storage to everyone who is moving anything to anywhere! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Andrea from Long Island

4.9 / 5
based on 8 reviews
Siracusa Moving & Storage, Inc Unclaimed
600 East Street New Britain, CT 06050 USA

Recent review:

Suresh Nair
Jun 4, 2020

They did a fantastic job with our move. The packers and unpackers on either end were very professional and efficient, the driver was also excellent! The back office staff kept me informed throughout. The cost of the move was also competitive and reasonable. Excellent experience overall.

4.2 / 5
based on 8 reviews
Avatar Relocation of NY Inc. Unclaimed
445 County Road 101 Unit J Yaphank, NY 11980-2300 USA

Recent review:

Denise Pasquarello
Apr 23, 2020

We did a move from Long Island to New Jersey. I can say enough good things about Avatar. Chris came to our house was very friendly and thorough, gave us tips and advice. Wasn’t pushy and pricing was very good. The guys who moved us were excellent- showed up on time - were very careful with our furniture and boxes. Polite, clean, professional and prompt. I can’t say enough good things about our experience with Avatar. I would definitely recommend them.

4.9 / 5
based on 8 reviews
46 Lewis Street Plainville, CT 06062 USA

Recent review:

Martin Glass
Jun 1, 2020

The movers were polite and professional. However, they were very slow to empty a two-bedroom apartment. It took them 5 3/4 hours for the move which was not completed by them since their truck was full. I moved 2 miles down the road, so it wasn't travel time in-between. They are paid by the hour with a three hour minimum. I moved myself (with three friends last year and it took us 4 hours). Wondering if they took their time to get paid more?

4.2 / 5
based on 8 reviews
17 Central Ave Hauppauge, NY 11788 USA

Recent review:

Rosy Stefanich
May 13, 2020

Liberty movers were amazing. Jesse was friendly, polite and on point. He made sure we had all of our items and went through it more than twice. I will be recommending them to everyone I know.

4.4 / 5
based on 8 reviews
Liberty Moving & Storage Co, Commack NY Unclaimed
350 Moreland Rd Commack, NY 11725-5707 USA

Recent review:

Rosy Stefanich
May 13, 2020

Liberty movers were amazing. Jesse was friendly, polite and on point. He made sure we had all of our items and went through it more than twice. I will be recommending them to everyone I know.

4.4 / 5
based on 8 reviews
100 Central Avenue New Haven, CT 06511 USA

Recent review:

Rebecca Porter
Mar 22, 2022

I would give zero Stars if I could. I called this company right after I rented a 10x17 storage unit. My uncle had just died and I needed to move his stuff. I paid $390 down and asked for a three-man crew but was told he only sent two men for a two-bedroom apartment. I told him I had one bedroom set, a living room set, a dining room set with a hutch, a den, a small kitchen table and chairs and about 35 to 45 boxes. My move was set up for 12 with a 2-hour window. The two guys, Eric and the other cranky guy that came with him showed up around 3:30. It took them approximately 4 hours to load half of the stuff onto the truck and said they couldn't fit anymore so we went to the storage. It took them another hour to get everything off of the truck and I was told I would probably need another storage unit as everything would not fit. They went back to the apartment and loaded everything back in around 11:00 p.m. they were done. When we got back to the storage, the unit was closed. It took them several tries to get the boss on the phone and he stated they would have to return all of my stuff back to Connecticut and he would return it the next day. I had no choice since the storage unit was closed. I spoke to the manager, Chris, myself and asked if it usually took this long since several years ago I had had a three bedroom apartment moved and it only took 4 hours for the whole thing. He became pretty incensed and asked how many men. When I told him only two men moved a three-bedroom apartment in 4 hours he asked me didn't I think things had changed since 2014 and I said no, why would it? Two guys show up with a truck, why would things get slower over the years instead of faster? He said if I didn't like it I could use another f***ing next time. I said okay, that is what reviews are for. He then swore at me and told me that I could find some other moving company to come and get my stuff he wasn't going to return my property and hung up. He then tried to run my debit card for $1,010. Since he never asked me or told me how much he was going to be charging, the money was not in the account because I transfer it once I'm told how much something is going to cost. I told him the job wasn't done and he told me that was what he was charging me for that day. I really believe he planned to hold my furniture hostage and charge me more money to get it back. I told him I was going to get an attorney. He started sending harassing texts like I had no right to ask questions and made it seem like I picked up some guys off the street to help move, not a company that was being paid. I called him the next morning and he told me he was only able to get $25 off of my card and that's all I had paid. I reminded him I had initially paid $390 which I had proof of. I was accused of not telling him the truth about how much stuff I had when I absolutely told him the size of the storage unit and what items I had. I also mentioned that I had a lawyer and had been given instruction on how to deal with him. He then told me this had been all a huge misunderstanding and he would send another crew with my stuff back and give me 20% off. I paid another $790. The second crew showed up and were much more professional and experienced as opposed to the first Crew he sent the day before. They actually had everything left off of the truck, repacked my storage unit and had everything fit from the day before and the items they bought back that day in less than 2 hours. I feel if they had come the day before, the job would have been done properly and in a less amount of time than the total of almost 11 hours it took to move a two-bedroom apartment. I ended up paying $1205. I have included texts he sent to me showing what an unprofessional and rude person he turned out to be. I have a big out-of-state move coming and I will never use a small unknown company like this. I will go back to the professional people that moved me years previously. What a scam this guy tried to pull!

4.3 / 5
based on 9 reviews
67 Mall Dr Commack, NY 11725-5703 USA

Recent review:

Marika Graham
Jun 1, 2020

Moving with Hall Lane was such a great decision! Richie was my first point of contact; he’s very responsive, kind, helpful and candid about pricing. My moving day went smoother than I could’ve imagined. The team was on time, they were friendly, not a single item was missing or damaged, and on top of it all, they were super fast! It was an easy move from start to finish.

4.7 / 5
based on 8 reviews
340 Quinnipiac St Wallingford, CT 06492 USA

Recent review:

Brendan McDermott
Jun 4, 2020

These guys were awesome. Due to a last minute foul up our closing was pushed and I had to reschedule movers. I called around but this company was easily the best. Flexible, accommodating they asked all the questions that they needed so the crew that arrived knew what to expect. When the crew arrived (early too which was a bonus) all 3 were friendly and professional. Loading was quick and simple, they even finished removing some of our items from a downstairs storage unit. Unloading was even faster with reassembly of the few items that needed it. Overall very well done start to finish. The crew, the office team all of them. I don't plan to move again anytime soon but if I do I'm calling them.

4.4 / 5
based on 8 reviews
Best Shelter Island Movers
Trusting strangers with your personal things is something that many people are not used to, and that is normal. That's why when you hire a company to move in, it's very important to choose a respectable, well-respected company that you will fully trust, one that will ease the stress of moving in and do it all at an affordable price. This list of the best moving companies in Shelter Island makes it easy and fast to move.
$531
avg moving cost
4 hours
2 movers